Breastfeeding, vaccination and allergies studies

[Guest guest]

Hi all,

have any of you come accross any studies that compare vaccinated, exclusively

breastfed or at least partially breastfed children (but preferrably excl. to

eliminate the possibility of allergies being caused by formula) to unvaccinated

children, exlc. bf children? I have googled like mad, even using google scholar

but many studies are not free of charge and the free ones are far and few

between. I need some more as I am collecting as many as I can for a project to

help babies be bresstfed and have complete benefit from breastmilk without the

problems that formula fed babies have and the problems that vaccines cause.

Thanks!

Ingrid (Scotland)

[Guest guest]

I haven't come across any except for the fact that my child was breastfed

until 11 months which she chose not to want it anymore. She was vaxxed until

she needed another Tetnus and MMR for school and then I became enlightened

My daughter does have some bad sensitivities going on but, we know what

those are through starting slow with the SCD. Jenn

Breastfeeding, vaccination and allergies studies

> Hi all,

> have any of you come accross any studies that compare vaccinated,

exclusively breastfed or at least partially breastfed children (but

preferrably excl. to eliminate the possibility of allergies being caused by

formula) to unvaccinated children, exlc. bf children? I have googled like

mad, even using google scholar but many studies are not free of charge and

the free ones are far and few between. I need some more as I am collecting

as many as I can for a project to help babies be bresstfed and have

complete benefit from breastmilk without the problems that formula fed

babies have and the problems that vaccines cause.

> Thanks!

> Ingrid (Scotland)

>

>

>

>

[Guest guest]

The breastfed vs. not breastfed would probably be easier to find than vaccinated

vs. unvaccinated, because the powers that be would be afraid of us seeing that

those who aren't vaccinated are healthier. My two boys were both breastfed, my

oldest son until he was two and my 3.5 year old is still nursing a couple of

times a day. My older son was vaccinated and has allergies and asthma. My

younger son hasn't shown any signs of any allergies, except ibuprofen, we gave

it to him once when he had stitches and he broke out in hives that went away

after about ten minutes. We have allergies on both sides of the family and my

husband has asthma, so the odds were against him to not show any other signs.

--

Sara

Proud Mama to

Colin 12/07/99

Jack 8/07/02

-------------- Original message --------------

From: Ingrid Schebesch <ingrid_schebesch@...>

Hi all,

have any of you come accross any studies that compare vaccinated, exclusively

breastfed or at least partially breastfed children (but preferrably excl. to

eliminate the possibility of allergies being caused by formula) to unvaccinated

children, exlc. bf children? I have googled like mad, even using google scholar

but many studies are not free of charge and the free ones are far and few

between. I need some more as I am collecting as many as I can for a project to

help babies be bresstfed and have complete benefit from breastmilk without the

problems that formula fed babies have and the problems that vaccines cause.

Thanks!

Ingrid (Scotland)

[Guest guest]

I have done my own little study, so not sure if this is worth anything to you.

My first two children are vaxxed and were breastfed only through 9 months, then

breastfed with some solids through 13 months when they weaned themselves. They

both were very sick babies. My oldest has epilepsy and the other has food

allergies. They both have seasonal & pet allergies as well. My 3rd child is

almost 5 months old. He is not vaxxed and is breastfed only. He is SO healthy

and so much healthier than my other two at this age. I am hoping that this is

the case for the rest of his life, too! Everyone always are remarking how alert

and happy he is for his age- he is very bright and already trying to sit up at 5

months, has been rolling around since 3 months, etc. Doing things sooner than my

other two.

Ingrid Schebesch <ingrid_schebesch@...> wrote: Hi all,

have any of you come accross any studies that compare vaccinated, exclusively

breastfed or at least partially breastfed children (but preferrably excl. to

eliminate the possibility of allergies being caused by formula) to unvaccinated

children, exlc. bf children? I have googled like mad, even using google scholar

but many studies are not free of charge and the free ones are far and few

between. I need some more as I am collecting as many as I can for a project to

help babies be bresstfed and have complete benefit from breastmilk without the

problems that formula fed babies have and the problems that vaccines cause.

Thanks!

Ingrid (Scotland)

Momma to Noah (2/16/01), (7/10/02), & Grayson (10/7/05)

http://adventuresinbabywearing.blogspot.com/

---------------------------------

Relax. virus scanning helps detect nasty viruses!

[Guest guest]

Hi Stepahanie,

thank you very much for this, can I keep your email and use it,

please? This is exactly what I find time and time again, the benefits

of bf are nullified or reduced by vacciantion so this can put many

potential bf mums off. I have had exactly the same experience with my

son, he was fine until his baby jabs and then he got bad eczema, in

spite of excl. bf, delayed solids etc.

Something is not right.

Thanks.

Ingrid

[Guest guest]

>

> Hi all,

> have any of you come accross any studies that compare vaccinated,

exclusively breastfed or at least partially breastfed children (but

preferrably excl. to eliminate the possibility of allergies being

caused by formula) to unvaccinated children, exlc. bf children? I have

googled like mad, even using google scholar but many studies are not

free of charge and the free ones are far and few between. I need some

more as I am collecting as many as I can for a project to help babies

be bresstfed and have complete benefit from breastmilk without the

problems that formula fed babies have and the problems that vaccines

cause.

> Thanks!

> Ingrid (Scotland)

>

>

>

>

[Guest guest]

Thank you very much for your reply; these kind of studies are probably

almost impossible to do as there are few excl. bf babies that are not

vaccinated. I will try a different method.

Ingrid

[Guest guest]

Isn't that the truth? I've spoken to many, many mums who have breastfed but

vaccinated, and then babe's gone on to get something that is normally

protected against by breastfeeding. Then it's " I did breastfeed but he/she

still got eczema/ asthma/ ear infections/ psoriasis/ IBS/ hayfever/ADHD/

whatever....so breastfeeding did a fat lot of good, didn't it? " ...and so it

goes on... No point in arguing - they won't listen. Friend back in

Somerset has 6yo lad who definitely has strong symptoms of ADHD, possibly

asperger's, breastfed him for a year or so, but then vaxed him fully. I

innocently asked one day if she'd given him the MMR and she got very

angry....I'm not sure she hadn't put two and two together and made four.

And she didn't like it...

Sad.

Sue

> Re: Breastfeeding, vaccination and allergies

> studies

>

>

> Hi Stepahanie,

> thank you very much for this, can I keep your email and use it,

> please? This is exactly what I find time and time again, the benefits

> of bf are nullified or reduced by vacciantion so this can put many

> potential bf mums off. I have had exactly the same experience with my

> son, he was fine until his baby jabs and then he got bad eczema, in

> spite of excl. bf, delayed solids etc.

> Something is not right.

> Thanks.

> Ingrid

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

[Guest guest]

Yes that's true. I'd say " study mine " - she was breastfed for 5½ years and

is totally unvaxed - but even then she has had exposure to formula when it

was given in hospital against my wishes. So she isn't even close to 100%

suitable for studying....(

Keep the faith, Ingrid. Maybe one day....

Sue

>

> Thank you very much for your reply; these kind of studies are probably

> almost impossible to do as there are few excl. bf babies that are not

> vaccinated. I will try a different method.

> Ingrid

>

>

[Guest guest]

What would'e happened to this baby if mom didn't breastfeed? My little one

was vaxed and breastfed and was very sick with allergies etc. Jenn L

Re: Breastfeeding, vaccination and allergies

> > studies

> >

> >

> > Hi Stepahanie,

> > thank you very much for this, can I keep your email and use it,

> > please? This is exactly what I find time and time again, the benefits

> > of bf are nullified or reduced by vacciantion so this can put many

> > potential bf mums off. I have had exactly the same experience with my

> > son, he was fine until his baby jabs and then he got bad eczema, in

> > spite of excl. bf, delayed solids etc.

> > Something is not right.

> > Thanks.

> > Ingrid

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

[Guest guest]

My dd has slight exzema, and I didnt vax he but breast fed her for 10 months

(then she

went on strike and I let her wean). I can only imagine what her skin would be

like if Id

vaccinated her?? It would be a mess!! My dh has exzema as does my son, also bf

and non

vax.. but he has grown out of the red patches and now has like.. bumpy skin on

his upper

arms.. but htats it (and an occasional patch above his bottom). I think part of

dd's

problem is she loves dairy.. cheese, yogurt, milk... I leave out the milk and

cheese for the

most part, but she eats yogurt practically every day. To offset this, I use

burts bees lotion

and a natural lavendar bath oil.... that paired with a daily omega 3 keep her

from breaking

out in huge red patches htat she scraches till they bleed.

>

> What would'e happened to this baby if mom didn't breastfeed? My little one

> was vaxed and breastfed and was very sick with allergies etc. Jenn L

> Re: Breastfeeding, vaccination and allergies

> > > studies

> > >

> > >

> > > Hi Stepahanie,

> > > thank you very much for this, can I keep your email and use it,

> > > please? This is exactly what I find time and time again, the benefits

> > > of bf are nullified or reduced by vacciantion so this can put many

> > > potential bf mums off. I have had exactly the same experience with my

> > > son, he was fine until his baby jabs and then he got bad eczema, in

> > > spite of excl. bf, delayed solids etc.

> > > Something is not right.

> > > Thanks.

> > > Ingrid

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >